Names in regular type refer to official designations, names in italics refer to previous names or local nicknames

  • Pacet Key
  • Palm Key
  • Palo Alto Key
  • Panhandle Key
  • Paps, The
  • Parida
  • Park Key (I)
  • Park Key (II)
  • Pass Key
  • Pavilion Key
  • Pearl City
  • Pelican Key (I)
  • Pelican Key (II)
  • Pelican Keys
  • Peninsula Larga
  • Pepper Key
  • Perkey
  • Peterson Keys
  • Pie Key
  • Pigeon Key (I)
  • Pigeon Key (II)
  • Pinero Grande
  • Plantar
  • Plantation Island
  • Plantation Key
  • Plover Key
  • Pollock Island
  • Pollock Keys
  • Pollux
  • Pond Key
  • Poor Craig's Key
  • Porgee Key
  • Porgy Key
  • Porjoe Key
  • Porpoise Island
  • Porpoise Key
  • Pownal Kay
  • Pownall Island
  • Pretty Joe Rock
  • Prickly Pear Key
  • Pumpkin Key (I)
  • Pumpkin Key (II)
  • Pye Key
  • Pye('s) Harbor Key